Left Page Border
Makes the header linkable

Go Back   The Final Horcrux > Discussions on Half-Blood Prince > HBP Analysis

HBP Analysis A deeper and meaningful look at the details of HBP

Reply
 
Thread Tools Rating: Thread Rating: 4 votes, 5.00 average. Display Modes
Old 16-12-2005, 15:45   #21
Fortescue
Totally Potterfied!
 
Fortescue's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: The wall next to Dumbledore . . .
Posts: 1,518
Rep Power: 16Fortescue will become famous soon enough

Re: Why did Snape kill Dumbledore?

Quote:
Originally Posted by SnarkologyMajor
Something I'm trying to sort out is the fact that Snape started teaching about a year after Lily and James were killed and he told Umbridge that he applied for the DADA job(and every yr. since) Now Snape had to have known that the position was cursed-it feels like it was done for his cover but..can't quite figure this out?? It seems important though...I'm also terrible with timelines! Any thoughts on this?
Snape actually began teaching at Hogwarts prior to the Potters death. The school year begins in Sept, and he told Umbridge in OotP that he had worked at Hogwarts for fourteen years, so that would have put him there at the beginning of the school year, almost two months before the Potters died.

The fact that Dumbledore knew the DADA job was cursed is interesting! If he knew it was cursed, why then did he give it to Snape that particular year? Was it as an excuse to show what Dumbledore and Snape wanted everyone to think were his true colors? Notice how Harry excelled at DADA every year, even the year that Umbridge taught the class, but only because of the DA and their private lessons. But, he went through an entire year in the class with Snape and couldn't learn to cast spells without saying the incantations??? It seems right along the lines of his not being able to do Occlumency because of the stress Snape created around Harry.

And that goes along with all of Harry's sixth year. Why was it that Dumbledore only taught Harry about Voldemort's past and Horcruxes when he was supposed to be the most powerful Wizard in the world? Then there's the potions book - the most informative potions book there probably ever was with all the notes and spells from the HBP himself - was it really just by chance that Slughorn gave Harry that particular book? First, Dumbledore knew Harry wouldn't buy a potions book because he didn't get the proper grade for Snape's level, so he would of course come to school unprepared for the class and just happen to fit into Slughorn's grade level for NEWT's. Second, would Snape leave his own potions book in the store cupboard where anyone could get it as he seemed awfully upset that Harry was using the spells he had made up. Was that just a stupid oversight on Snape's part, or did it all happen for a reason???

Was Dumbledore's death something the two of them had planned for a long time? Possibly since Harry first came to Hogwarts or before? Look at how many years Harry was at Hogwarts before Dumbledore told him how he truly felt about him? I think Harry's fifth year was Dumbledore's final chance to tell Harry how much he cared, because maybe he knew he wouldn't live to see the end of his sixth year!
__________________
What did I care if numbers of nameless and faceless people and creatures were slaughtered in the vague future, if in the here and now you were alive, and well, and happy?
Albus Dumbledore



"I miss having you in my classes, Harry, you were never much of a Seer . . . but you were a wonderful Object . . . "
Sybil Trelawney
Fortescue is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 16-12-2005, 20:43   #22
Sirius Potter Fan
Night Patroll
 
Sirius Potter Fan's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Tulsa, OK USA
Age: 54
Posts: 1,690
Rep Power: 16Sirius Potter Fan is on a distinguished road

Re: Why did Snape kill Dumbledore?

First Forte, I like the idea of it being Dumbledore teaching Snape Occlumency. That would make perfect sense of why he asked Snape to teach harry, because he had taught him himself, and expected that Snape would teach Harry int he same way.

I don't think Dumbledore's death had been planned for a long time, I think it had been worked out as soon as Snape heard of Draco's job. I think Snape finaly getting the DADA job was just that Dumbledore and Snape knew that since Snape would have to kill DD at some point in the year, That Snape wouldn't be teaching the next year anyway, and it would just seem that the curse continued. It was possibly Dumbledore's belief that tthe position was cursed, that kept him from putting Snape in the position in the first place, he wanted Snape to stay at the school, so he couldn't give him the DADA position untill he knew that he wouldn't be able to return the next year.
__________________
Where your treasure is, there will your heart be also.
His memory will live on . . .




There is no place I know to compare with pure imagination; living there you'll be free, if you truly wish to be.
_Willy Wonka

Murphy's Law: "Whatever can go wrong, will."

Mad-eye Moody's Law: "Murphy was an optimist!"
Sirius Potter Fan is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 17-12-2005, 01:49   #23
Alz
Head Unspeakable
 
Alz's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: West Coast US, originally UK!!
Age: 45
Posts: 7,108
Rep Power: 10Alz is on a distinguished road

Re: Why did Snape kill Dumbledore?

OK - last point is the killer point and also explain the answer to many things ...
So - Dumbledore gives Snape the job he so wants - knowing that the curse wont allow Snape to do more than a year ...
Makes perfect sense!
Snape would have come to Dumbledore straight after he made the unbreakable vow - Dumbledore knew that he would have to die at some point - Snape wouldnt be around because he had a large hand in it - so gives him the job as his final tribute to Snape ... might even sweeten the deal which will see Snape have to kill him!
He then sets about making preparations for his death - well organised mind and all he had months to set in month any plans he wanted to make before the fateful moment.
See he knew he was going to have to die - he knew Snape wouldnt be around in a year and might have even been a great test of Voldemort - will Voldemort allow one of his spies to die by the curse he placed on the position - like forcing Voldemort's hand!
The killer point is that before the school year commenced - Dumbledore knew he was going to have to die in order for Snape to live and continue in the quest - all it did was give him time and we know that he was missing for large parts of the year and the explanation was he was Horcrux hunting - I think he was organising things for the next great adventure!
__________________
'It's all my fault, all my fault'
'Please make it stop, I know I did wrong, oh, please make it stop and i'll never, never again..'
'Don't hurt them, don't hurt then, please, please, it's my fault, hurt me instead ...'
'Please, please, please, no ... not that, not that, I'll do anything ...'

Dumbledore - HBP Pg536

'Merely taking your life would not satisfy me..'
Dumbledore - OoTP "The only one he ever feared" Pg895
Alz is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 17-12-2005, 02:54   #24
SnarkologyMajor
TFH Graduate
 
SnarkologyMajor's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: South Bend, IN - Lost in my pensieve
Age: 52
Posts: 418
Rep Power: 15SnarkologyMajor will become famous soon enough

Re: Why did Snape kill Dumbledore?

Yes-this is starting to make sense! I knew you guys would grasp that timing thing better than me-I wasn't even thinking of when the school yr. started This does seem like it was planned all yr. that Snape may have to kill Dumbledore in the end. When you consider that Voldemort now knows that there was more to the prophecy than what he heard and Snape was the one who left out the pertinent part that led to his downfall-Why on earth should he trust Snape without question! Snape's great at covering his tracks-but Voldemort is not stupid. What better way to prove his loyalty than by killing Dumbledore?Or by Dumbledore giving him the DADA position he himself cursed?Dumbledore and Snape must have at least made plans when they found out about Voldemort's plan w/Draco. Of course this doesn't really clear up the matter of whether or not Albus's death was faked. On one hand I feel that Dumbledore was well prepared to die for the greater good-he certainly didn't fear death! And if you think about it- Dumbledore's mishandling of young Tom from the beginning sort of created this whole mess! When you see what happens to Dumbledore in the cave-it makes you realize the pain he must feel at carrying that weight. It fits with what he says to Amycus-
pg. 594 "Oh, weaker resistance, slower reflexes, Amycus," said Dumbledore."Old age in short...One day, perhaps, it will happen to you...if you are lucky..."
If by his death he could right some of the wrong-that would be a sacrifice he wouldn't hesitate about.Combined with everything else happening on that tower-I think I just convinced myself that he's really dead I still cling to the hope that he was already gone when Snape cast his Avada Kedavra.
SnarkologyMajor is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 17-12-2005, 07:46   #25
Fortescue
Totally Potterfied!
 
Fortescue's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: The wall next to Dumbledore . . .
Posts: 1,518
Rep Power: 16Fortescue will become famous soon enough

Re: Why did Snape kill Dumbledore?

Quote:
Originally Posted by SnarkologyMajor
When you consider that Voldemort now knows that there was more to the prophecy than what he heard and Snape was the one who left out the pertinent part that led to his downfall-Why on earth should he trust Snape without question!
I don't know if this might mean anything, but remember at the beginning of HBP at Snape's house when Pettigrew was there with him. The two people who had given Voldemort information that lead to his downfall were together!

Snape told him the bit of the prophecy that Voldemort could garner no useful information from, possibly fed to Voldemort directly from Dumbledore.

Pettigrew gave Voldemort the information of where the Potters were hiding and when he went there to kill them, well, you know what happened. (This makes me think of the thread where we discussed other things that might have been done to Harry, 'spells, potions, etc.' in order to assure he lived through any curse Voldemort shot at him!)

Is there a significance to the two of them being together after Voldemort had no need of Pettigrew anymore? I mean, why would the only two people who had given Voldemort incomplete information have been together when all these things came together? Could Wormtail be a bit more involved with all this then we have been lead to believe?

When I think about the sacrifice Dumbledore made to ensure that Harry could go on with his destiny, it makes me wonder if there wasn't a bunch more people who made great personal sacrifices for the same reason! The Potters, Sirius, etc...
__________________
What did I care if numbers of nameless and faceless people and creatures were slaughtered in the vague future, if in the here and now you were alive, and well, and happy?
Albus Dumbledore



"I miss having you in my classes, Harry, you were never much of a Seer . . . but you were a wonderful Object . . . "
Sybil Trelawney
Fortescue is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 27-01-2006, 12:05   #26
Seeker615
Ghosthunter
 
Seeker615's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: New York
Posts: 291
Rep Power: 15Seeker615 is on a distinguished road

Re: Why did Snape kill Dumbledore?

I have always loved Snape's character. JK did an amazing job at writing this character and he is always a great read whether youlove or hate the guy.

I personally feel that Snape is on the good side.

Right from the Spinner's End chapter when he was explaining himself the Bellatrix you could see the lies in his story. He tells Bella that Harry has no special powers. Snape knows Harry is gifted. He has seen Harry do some amazing things. Also Snape says Dumbledore was wounded from his last encounter with Voldemort. not true. He was injured getting the horcrux.( Which also has me wondering... Snape could have killed Dumbledore while he was wounded getting that horcrux. It would have looked like an accident)There were a few other stories in that chapter but I don't have my book with me at the moment.

There is the matter of Hagrid overhearing the arguement with Snape and Dumbledore. He was saying he didn't want to do it anymore. Do what? I don't thik he was telling Dumbledore he wanted to stop being on the good side. I think he was trying to back out of a pact he made with Dumbledore. (possibly about having to sacrifice Dumbledore if the time came?)

Now we come to that tower chapter. Do we know for sure that Snape even really stunned Flitwick? Flitwick never said he was stunned. Maybe he was already injured when he went to get Snape and really did collapse in his office. If he was so evil why didn't he just off Flitwick and the girls to get them out of the way. I really can't see any reason for him to stun Flitwick.

Now Snape gets to the tower and sees Draco and the DE's surrounding a helpless Dumbledore. Dumbledore is dying. It is too late to save him. (I think if these events didn't play out Snape would have been able to save him) Now Snape goes to the front of the pack and a moment is exchanged between the two men. Dumbledore utters those words "Severus Please" and Snape kills him. Dumbledore would not plead for his life. He was reminding Snape that he made a promise and for the good of this mission Dumbledore will need to make this sacrifice as well as Snape.

Lastly- When Harry and Snape exchange words in the forest Snape is clearly hurt when harry calls him a coward. I really think that Snape was upset over what he needed to do. He killed a man who gave him respect and trust. Also even though Snape does not like Harry he was in a way teaching him by telling him he needs to learn to close his mind.

Sorry about my rambling...
Seeker615 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 27-01-2006, 15:28   #27
Fortescue
Totally Potterfied!
 
Fortescue's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: The wall next to Dumbledore . . .
Posts: 1,518
Rep Power: 16Fortescue will become famous soon enough

Re: Why did Snape kill Dumbledore?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Alz
He then sets about making preparations for his death - well organised mind and all he had months to set in month any plans he wanted to make before the fateful moment.
Okay, I read through all this again and this sort of jumped right out at me. Remember when Dumbledore destroyed the Sorcerer's Stone and told Harry that Flamel had enough elixer left to set his affairs in order. So Dumbledore's partner knew he was going to die and had time to make plans to tie up loose ends before his number was up.

Dumbledore knew he was going to die, and like his partner, made his plans. It makes sense that regardless of how long Dumbledore knew he would die, the fact is that he knew the entire year at least. He didn't just get shot over the edge of the tower by Snape. He knew what was going on. He might not have known of the exact second, or even the exact way he would die, but considering all that was going on, Dumbledore had to know that Voldemort would try and make a major move before the school year was up. With Snape's vow, Dumbledore's burned hand, the supposedly, deadly potion in the basin and the fact that there had been two assasination attempts on Dumbledore's life that year, the man had to know his time was drawing short.

So he planned and schemed. Remember Scrimgeours question to Harry about where Dumbledore was all year and what he was up to.....we were lead to believe that he was only out seeking the location of Horcruxes - but was he?
__________________
What did I care if numbers of nameless and faceless people and creatures were slaughtered in the vague future, if in the here and now you were alive, and well, and happy?
Albus Dumbledore



"I miss having you in my classes, Harry, you were never much of a Seer . . . but you were a wonderful Object . . . "
Sybil Trelawney
Fortescue is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 28-01-2006, 03:14   #28
Alz
Head Unspeakable
 
Alz's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: West Coast US, originally UK!!
Age: 45
Posts: 7,108
Rep Power: 10Alz is on a distinguished road

Re: Why did Snape kill Dumbledore?

Both those last posts are excellent - thanks for Seeker and Forte - I think between the both of you, you have captured the essence of the situtation perfectly!

The ultimate answer to this question is simple - why did Snape kill Dumbledore - because he promised Dumbledore he would ... but the real genuis and also the facts so well bought out in this discussion is the really subtle undertones that spins the situation - in natural, uninformed reading it would suggest Snape is evil and kills Dumbledore dead ... it is only understanding what happened to get there that you see the real motivations - great posts Seeker and Forte!
__________________
'It's all my fault, all my fault'
'Please make it stop, I know I did wrong, oh, please make it stop and i'll never, never again..'
'Don't hurt them, don't hurt then, please, please, it's my fault, hurt me instead ...'
'Please, please, please, no ... not that, not that, I'll do anything ...'

Dumbledore - HBP Pg536

'Merely taking your life would not satisfy me..'
Dumbledore - OoTP "The only one he ever feared" Pg895
Alz is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 30-01-2006, 07:24   #29
Seeker615
Ghosthunter
 
Seeker615's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: New York
Posts: 291
Rep Power: 15Seeker615 is on a distinguished road

Re: Why did Snape kill Dumbledore?

Thanks Alz!

I have been spending a lot of time since HBP came out trying to find out why Snape did what he did. I just know there is so much more to the story then what we initially see.

I keep thinking in the end Snape will be the one to help Harry with the Horcruxes.
__________________
"It is our choices that show us what we truly are, far more than our abilities."
Albus Dumbledore: Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets.
Seeker615 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 30-01-2006, 11:38   #30
Alz
Head Unspeakable
 
Alz's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: West Coast US, originally UK!!
Age: 45
Posts: 7,108
Rep Power: 10Alz is on a distinguished road

Re: Why did Snape kill Dumbledore?

Well in support of that last comment - who did Dumbledore call for after his two horcrux endeavours?
Thinking logically - he asked for Snape on both occasions - doesn't this have to be more than magic strength, because I would have Dumbledore above Snape in strength and power - yet he calls for Snape for him hand and also after he consumes the potion.
Is it because of potions - well second time around maybe but why the ring as well?
I think there is a link between Snape, and the Horcrux powers - could lend weight to he knows a little more than most about these things.
__________________
'It's all my fault, all my fault'
'Please make it stop, I know I did wrong, oh, please make it stop and i'll never, never again..'
'Don't hurt them, don't hurt then, please, please, it's my fault, hurt me instead ...'
'Please, please, please, no ... not that, not that, I'll do anything ...'

Dumbledore - HBP Pg536

'Merely taking your life would not satisfy me..'
Dumbledore - OoTP "The only one he ever feared" Pg895
Alz is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


  Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2020, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:50.
Style Designed by Epic Designz
 
 

Harry Potter & all associated names and images remain the property of J.K Rowling, Bloomsbury Publishers UK and AOL Time Warner.All other logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner. The comments are property of their posters, all the rest 2005 by The Final Horcrux.
You are not permitted to hotlink/hyperlink any images from the site.
Please respect the intellectual rights of The Final Horcrux. You must contact the webmaster/administrator of The Final Horcrux if you wish to take any part of the site and contents for reproduction on another site, forum, or other web presence. Any site that plagiarises The Final Horcrux will be subject to a complaint being registered against them.
 

Right Page Border