Percy: The Spy?

[Alz]

You see - this is like DiE isnt it - you either get it or you dont - my brain fights this one head on ...
This could be yet another fantastic piece of decepive writing by JKR - and yah she is capable of it - we all know that .... but my mind fights the idea and just says Percy is a class A plonker that will be dead by Book 7 ...

As I said - I found the thread starter to be compelling and interesting - very well observed and also plausible in that manner - but in the context of what we know about Percy - well plonker every time!

[Kingsley]

Ok I think I have a better view than I did earlier on this

Remember when Percy was dating Penelope--he was very secretive and didnt break rules but he still didnt let anyone know what he was doing

Being Arthur and Dumbledore's spy wouldnt be against the rules really--he is only following the ministry like he is supposed to--while maybe contacting the order when he needs to--which technically isnt against the rules

[Mr_Bandman]

I'm digging around from thread to thread looking for any mention of this----please point me in the right direction if it's elsewhere: I had a forehead slapping revelation, which might be my own naivety and I may be the last person in the world to put this together----please tell me----it will not hurt my feelings----but it occurred to me that Scabbers was Percy's rat. That was no accident, and when I consider that fact along with Ron's jokes comparing Percy to Tom Riddle (Ron is almost always accidentally right when he's joking)----anyway, is there something really dangerous about Percy?