Left Page Border
Makes the header linkable

Go Back   The Final Horcrux > Discussion on Deathly Hallows > Post Release Discussions

Thread Tools Rate Thread Display Modes
Old 23-07-2007, 22:57   #1
TFH Graduate
Join Date: Aug 2005
Age: 49
Posts: 389
Rep Power: 14Piper is on a distinguished road

Fidelius Charm/Grimmauld Place

In DH, Hermoine says that when Dumbledore died, they all became secret-keepers, so they could not return to Grimmauld place because she had given Yaxley the secret.

This was not my understanding of how JKR answered the question of what happens with the secret-keeper dies their secret dies with them. She said that everyone to whom Dumbledore had confided the secret would continue to know but no one else. This was the result of a FAQ poll.

Am I missing something here, or is this a huge contradiction?

For some reason, it will let me edit this, but it will not let me post again to reply??

Last edited by Piper; 27-07-2007 at 13:26.. Reason: Question at end
Piper is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 24-07-2007, 06:29   #2
Tonks's Avatar
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: USA
Age: 30
Posts: 1,420
Rep Power: 16Tonks is on a distinguished road

Re: Fidelius Charm/Grimmauld Place

Here are her exact words:
J.K. Rowling's Official Website

What happens to a secret when the Secret-Keeper dies?

I was surprised that this question won, because it is not the one that I'd have voted for… but hey, if this is what you want to know, this is what you want to know!

When a Secret-Keeper dies, their secret dies with them, or, to put it another way, the status of their secret will remain as it was at the moment of their death. Everybody in whom they confided will continue to know the hidden information, but nobody else.

Just in case you have forgotten exactly how the Fidelius Charm works, it is

"an immensely complex spell involving the magical concealment of a secret inside a single, living soul. The information is hidden inside the chosen person, or Secret-Keeper, and is henceforth impossible to find -- unless, of course, the Secret-Keeper chooses to divulge it" (Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban)

In other words, a secret (eg, the location of a family in hiding, like the Potters) is enchanted so that it is protected by a single Keeper (in our example, Peter Pettigrew, a.k.a. Wormtail). Thenceforth nobody else – not even the subjects of the secret themselves – can divulge the secret. Even if one of the Potters had been captured, force fed Veritaserum or placed under the Imperius Curse, they would not have been able to give away the whereabouts of the other two. The only people who ever knew their precise location were those whom Wormtail had told directly, but none of them would have been able to pass on the information.
The easiest and kind of cheap way out for this one would be to say that Hermione was mistaken... it could just be an inconsistency [they're bound to happen sometimes i suppose]..

I wonder that it was even possible for Yaxley to Apparate onto the doorstep of #12 Grimmauld Place following them. I feel like he should have wound up back at the Ministry or outside in the courtyard of Grimmauld Place because he should not be able to have access to that doorstep or the house beyond.

"Remember Cedric. Remember, if the time should come when you have to make a choice between what is right and what is easy, remember what happened to a boy who was good, and kind, and brave, because he strayed across the path of Lord Voldemort. Remember Cedric Diggory."
- Albus Dumbledore
Tonks is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 24-07-2007, 06:51   #3
Padma Patil
Dumbledore's Girl
Padma Patil's Avatar
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: South East Minnesota
Age: 31
Posts: 440
Rep Power: 14Padma Patil is on a distinguished road

Re: Fidelius Charm/Grimmauld Place

I'm kinda agreeing with Tonks here. I mean Hermione didn't exactly tell Yaxley where the house is, so the secret should have been safe still. I mean I suppose she could have been right, that by her taking him there she gave him the secret nonverbally. But I'm thinking of what Harry had to do to get inside the house. He had to read a note from the secret-keeper (Dumbledore) and then think about what he had read in order for the house to appear. Thats inconsistant with how Hermione is suggesting it happened.

As to the quote, that is a bit of an inconsistancy, isn't it?
My Wand ~ Made of Hickory, 13 1/4" long, with a Billywig Stinger core...

"Look . . . at . . . me. . . ." he whispered.
- Severus Snape
DH pg. 658 Ch. 32 (US edition)
Padma Patil is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25-07-2007, 00:21   #4
TFH Graduate
happy_hannah's Avatar
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Age: 31
Posts: 187
Rep Power: 13happy_hannah is on a distinguished road

Re: Fidelius Charm/Grimmauld Place

well it says that "Everybody in whom they confided will continue to know the hidden information, but nobody else." so in a way as they all knew the whereabouts, they were all kind of secret keepers
"May born witches will marry muggles"
happy_hannah is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25-07-2007, 11:08   #5
Sirius Potter Fan
Night Patroll
Sirius Potter Fan's Avatar
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Tulsa, OK USA
Age: 52
Posts: 1,690
Rep Power: 15Sirius Potter Fan is on a distinguished road

Re: Fidelius Charm/Grimmauld Place

I too was initially confused about that incident
Everybody in whom they confided will continue to know the hidden information, but nobody else."
OK, this says to me that no one else could ever give away the secret no matter what, but . . . that wouldn't be too practical in reality . . . The house was now Harry's, of course just about everyone he knew had been given the secret initialy so they new where it was, but what of when Harry grows old, members of the Order are dead, family and friends die off, Would Harry's children be able to come home from school? I think . . . this is just a little oversite in JKR's planning . . . c'mon folks, JKR is brilliant to have kept as much consistant as she did. This is indeed fiction, and sometimes when you are the one making up all the laws and properties of a fictional world, it is possible that you may need to rethink a situation later on.
Where your treasure is, there will your heart be also.
His memory will live on . . .

There is no place I know to compare with pure imagination; living there you'll be free, if you truly wish to be.
_Willy Wonka

Murphy's Law: "Whatever can go wrong, will."

Mad-eye Moody's Law: "Murphy was an optimist!"
Sirius Potter Fan is offline   Reply With Quote

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

  Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 16:31.
Style Designed by Epic Designz

Harry Potter & all associated names and images remain the property of J.K Rowling, Bloomsbury Publishers UK and AOL Time Warner.All other logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner. The comments are property of their posters, all the rest 2005 by The Final Horcrux.
You are not permitted to hotlink/hyperlink any images from the site.
Please respect the intellectual rights of The Final Horcrux. You must contact the webmaster/administrator of The Final Horcrux if you wish to take any part of the site and contents for reproduction on another site, forum, or other web presence. Any site that plagiarises The Final Horcrux will be subject to a complaint being registered against them.

Right Page Border